Skip to content

Validators are marked for removal but haven't removed #421

Open @gmorgachev opened 2025-11-07 22:56 UTC 3 comments Updated 2026-02-12 15:25 UTC
bug up-for-grabs

Validators are marked for removal but haven't removed. Happens in cosmos-sdk 

7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1p5zz3d87hy5gn5jphhnljkv7pg06xj6gaa7g6p status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDED
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1rqpallfz6y9nukjhyvcv27zwtjptxph0qtvsjf status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1rk4ftnqp2pehy0scq3nl3d7nwe0ssq32jpyn9f status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1pu7kmkx300rj02z7tjffhkdtnas7cdcymcgzqm status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1yqamx9y94xnytgp9dzped2av7th6r8a57r56ls status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1d22n3vhrslellmxecscr49m0wtv6fva4gavcya status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1lzwf6hx5qlct2dx5szj4yrqappxjfzh0eft38s status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1x7zh2277spp7jfqjhv0g5mnezg290xdrfkswym status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1ap0lnyema9tt9mld8zgf6kl0ptqj8z5g5mh3ec status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper18lluv53n4h9z34qu20vxcvypgdkhsg6n02fcaq status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1jjm60sezst40nmtmj6l0cj0evax7lyg8lhv023 status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1sqwpuxkspyp483l64knd5rp6qp56ymj4s6f6sh status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1ygv9tv8fthcd43xeehfwagvrud66w9lvt9u3cg status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1lf8zrnapty4nny6l9dr66nd7xc4j4ktrxrd4qs status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1pzuq9ygxfrcp5e6qdzu2py5qgcw5gqvd978vcx status=BOND_STATUS_BONDED
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=false module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper16rt63h7ens8dvnf5nhl7yxtkkw7pc7q0ux6ckt status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING
7:48AM INF marking validator for removal (not in compute results) jailed=true module=x/staking operator=gonkavaloper1ux4gjvk07z6utgjqs3ttwk9lzr4cn7y0k295rn status=BOND_STATUS_UNBONDING

Happens here: https://github.com/gonka-ai/cosmos-sdk/blob/1ace5dd25d1a78f6b189cbdfec9b76839fe45a20/x/staking/keeper/compute.go#L166

💬 Comments (3)

@tcharchian commented 2026-01-28 22:19 UTC

Needs to be rechecked

@AlexeySamosadov commented 2026-02-08 15:16 UTC

PR: https://github.com/gonka-ai/gonka/pull/720

@AlexeySamosadov commented 2026-02-12 15:25 UTC

I already have a PR for this: #720 — it implements validator removal cleanup hooks. Would appreciate a review when you get a chance.

🔄 Auto-synced from Issue #421 every hour.